Re: Michael Fried’s Opposition to “Situation” and “Theatricality” – May ’68 at The University of Paris

Posted: March 8, 2018 in Uncategorized

From my IT1 class, Fall 2011:

The soul is the effect and instrument of political anatomy;
the soul is the prison of the body.
Michel Foucault

As I tried to point out in class, a very large (albeit unspoken) determining factor behind Jean-Pierre Vernant‘s study of classical antiquity was the contemporary political climate in which he was writing. During WWII, France, and in particular the capital city of Paris, had been occupied by the Germans and administrated by the cooperating Vichy government. After the war, the fiercely nationalist de Gaul government, along with the liberal social institutions maintained by it, continued, to many radical thinkers, to mirror too closely the oppressive regime from under which France had just emerged. This new order seemed simply to be a softer and more insidious version of the older order, one vast self-regulating penitentiary.

Or, groups such as Situationist International (the source from whence were stolen the look, attitude and slogans of first-wave British punk), saw modern French life, and in particular students life, as a state of perpetual captivity to ubiquitous banality and boredom. Consequently, leading intellectuals, motivated students (the diametrical opposite of the quintessential ‘good student’ in the Honors College) and industrial laborers, banded together, set up barricades against police attack, and sought to reclaim their access to an educational system they considered to have been stolen from them by the established regime.

One of the principle wings of this intellectual and political resistance to authority was the Anti-Psychiatric Movement, which arose in reaction to the pervasiveness of Freudian psychology through French academics and therapeutics. One of the classic statements (still widely read and taught today) of this movement was a volume co-authored by philosopher Gilles Deleuze and psychiatrist Felix Guattari (a specialist in psychosis), Anti-Oedipus. This landmark text, which unmasked that numerous oppositional drives and desires held in a state in extreme “tension and ambiguity” by Freud’s socially constructed and reinforced Oedipal Complex, seeks to challenge compulsory and normative neurosis with a post-psychological view of the schizoid body; a restless and excessive anti-Human body which recognizes no rules of due proportion or any ‘golden mean,’ but rather manifests itself as a perpetually mobile ‘desiring-machine’. Meanwhile, society at large might be seen, according to Deleuze and Guattari, as a vast apparatus of physical forms and conventional signs designed to restrict and channel the intensive flows and surges of libidinal forces and bodily energies – this in opposition to the rationalist Cartesian body (or automaton), which is understood as mere res extensa, matter extended in space.

When the act of narration becomes as integral to the total story as the actions narrated, as motivated by restless urges, as fraught with perils, pains and ecstasies; then the story suddenly bristles, an automaton turned inside out. All the inner devices of poetics are exposed, brought into plain view. The author is revealed to be a writing machine. His desires now figure as mere drives, his unfathomable creative force as hydraulic differential flow. With this inversion the artist passes beyond himself, outside his ego. Likewise, the work of art, originally and reassuringly emblematized by the scenes of peace and plenty contained within the gilt frame of the shield of Achilles, inverts itself. Its cogs, planes, levers, screws and pulleys, its ropes and bellows now exposed and live (as wires are said to be live); the work of art then becomes Deleuze’s war machine, Vaucanson’s famous defecating duck gone on a killing spree. The horror . . . and the hilarity.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s